Background
India’s fight against Tuberculosis (TB) has evolved from the National Tuberculosis (TB) Control Program (NTCP) in 1962 to the current National TB Elimination Program (NTEP), guided by the National Strategic Plan (2020–2025). Despite ambitious goals, TB incidence remains high at 199 cases per lakh, with only a 3% annual reduction, far from the 15% target. Systemic issues, especially in human resources, hamper effective policy implementation. Frontline workers (FWs), crucial to the program, face heavy workloads, inadequate upgradation of training, and limited support, yet their voices are rarely heard. This study uses Lipsky’s Street-Level Bureaucracy (SLB) theory to explore FWs’ challenges under NTEP and offers insights to strengthen India’s TB elimination efforts.
Method
Twenty-three in-depth interviews were conducted with frontline workers (FWs) in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region, a TB hotspot. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and thematically coded using a deductive approach informed by Lipsky’s Street-Level Bureaucracy (SLB) theory.
Results
Three key themes emerged: (1) TB program-specific contextual challenges, (2) human resource constraints, and (3) leadership support. Consistent with street-level bureaucracy theory, frontline workers, despite the formal constraints of their contractual employment, exercised practical discretion to manage high workloads, adverse working conditions, and limited resources.. Supervisory leadership style influenced worker attitudes, transformational leadership fostered motivation and greater engagement with program activities , whereas transactional leadership was linked to dissatisfaction and program alienation.
Conclusion
Difficult working conditions coupled with resource deficits hinder effective program implementation. However, supervisory leadership significantly shapes FWs’ engagement with program objectives, highlighting its critical role in advancing TB elimination efforts. We recommend improving working conditions for TB health workers by addressing staff shortages, offering risk-based incentives such as paid leave, medical insurance, and nutritional support, and ensuring safer workplaces. Additionally, effective leadership training for District TB Officers, City TB Officers, and Medical Officers, along with recognition and capacity-building for frontline workers such as TB Health Visitors (TBHVs), is crucial.
