Research Productive

Show result

Search Query :
Area :
Search Query :
3552 items in total found

Working Papers | 2000

Threshold of Median Rank Solutions

Lahiri Somdeb

In this paper we consider solutions defined on the class of transitive tournaments. Such solutions are essentially rank solutions i.e. solutions which depend on the ranks of the alternatives and not on any other physical characteristic. A solution is said to be a threshold solution, if for every feasible set of alternatives there exists an alternative such that the solution set coincides with the set of feasible alternatives which are not worse than the assigned alternative. We provide an axiomatic characterization of such solutions using two properties. The first property is functional acyclicity. The second property requires that given any set containing just two alternatives only the alternative only the alternative with the higher rank is selected. In order to make the presentation self contained we also provide a simple proof of an extension theorem, which is used to prove two the above mentioned axiomatic characterization. Subsequently, we provide two theorems which characterizes the median choice function when the universal set has atleast three alternatives. Several examples are provided to highlight the relationship between the axioms emphasised in this paper. It is also noted here that our second axiomatic characterization breaks down if the universal set contains precisely two elements. Following our discussion of the median rank solution, we provide two more axiomatic characterization. The first is a simultaneous axiomatic characterization of two solutions: one being that which always chooses the element with the highest rank form a set and the other being that which always selects the element with the lowest rank from a set. The second is also a simultaneous axiomatic characterization of two solutions: one being that which always chooses the greatest element from the median choice set of a set and the other being that which always selects the least element from the median choice set of a set.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

Abstract Games Admitting Stable Solutions

Lahiri Somdeb

Reflexive and complete binary relations are also referred to as abstract games. An ordered pair comprising a non-empty subset of the universal set and an abstract game is referred to as a subgame. A (game) solution is a function which associates to all subgames of a given (nonempty) set of games, a nonempty subset of the set in the subgame. In this paper we obtain conditions which are either necessary or sufficient for an abstract game to admit a solution which always selects a von Neumann-Morgenstern stable set from every admissible subgame. It is proved in this paper that a sufficient condition for an abstract game to satisfy this property is that it does not admit any strict preference cycle of length three and satisfy what we call stable five element set property. We show by an example that these two properties are logically independent.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

Local Social Decision Functions: A Survey

Lahiri Somdeb

Since the publication of Arrow's (1951) impossibility theorem, much effort has been spent on the analysis and rationalizability of committee decision making. The traditional approach to this problem considers rules which aggregate individual binary relations to a binary relation for society. In this survey we call such rules, which are assumed to be defined on profiles of individual rankings, by the name social decision functions. In Aleskerov (1999) can be found a property that social decision functions are required to satisfy. This property is called locality. In Arrow's original work it was called independence of irrelevant alternatives. Social Decision functions which satisfy locality are called local social decision functions. Aleskerov (1999) not only contains a state of the art survey of local social decision functions, but several original contributions to the literature as well. However, Aleskerov does not restrict the domain of social decision functions to be profiles of individual rankings. In different characterization of individual rankings as a subset and usually as a strict subset. It is well known in the theory of axiomatic choice theory that a characterization valid on a given domain may fail to hold on a subdomain. Our purpose in this survey is to show that such is not the case with local social decision functions. It is necessary to justify the domain we have chosen for our survey. Social sciences in general and economic theory in particular, has never confronted any major problem while representing individual preferences by a strict ranking. It is only the issue concerning social preferences by a strict ranking which has been at the centre of the debate concerning aggregation of preferences in social choice theory. Thus the domain comprising profiles of individual rankings is consistent with the demands of economic theory and yet highlights the problems that arise very naturally in social aggregation procedures.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

Privatisation: Issues and Evidence

T. T. Ram Mohan

Even as India's privatisation programme gathers steam, there is a perception, reflected in the pronouncements of ministers as well as in writings in the popular press, that the benefits of privatisation can be taken as axiomatic. There is little in the literature on privatisation that lends support to such dogma. The theoretical literature, while pointing to the benefits or private ownership, also underlines the conditions under which such benefits an be realised. These conditions cannot be presumed to operate everywhere. The empirical evidence is also shrouded in ambiguities, whether we look at the experience in the developed world or in developing countries. This paper surveys the literature on privatisation and highlights the conceptual issues underlying privatisation as well as the evidence from privatisation experiments in different parts of the world.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

eTime

Singh J P

The paper examines various measures of time and argues that none of the measures meet the needs of commerce and law for transactions carried out in the cyberspace. It therefore suggests that a new measure of the time and epoch, called eTime be introduced. The paper further suggests that the assumed zero of eTime should be the epoch of signing 'A Declaration of Independence of Cyberspace', i.e. Fri, Feb 9, 1996 17:16:35 +0100 at Davos, Switzerland.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

The Lexicographic Composition of Abstract Games

Lahiri Somdeb

Two stage selection procedures are quite common. Decisions arrived at on the basis of the composition of the binary relations in some form, is what is implemented in such two stage choice procedures. The resulting binary relation is referred to as a lexicographic composition of the individual binary relations. In this paper we begin by obtaining a necessary and sufficient condition for a quasi transitive binary relation to be transitive. Then we obtain necessary and sufficient conditions for the lexicographic composition of two quasi transitive binary relations to be quasi transitive. In passing it is noted that the lexicographic composition of two transitive binary relations is always transitive. Finally, we obtain conditions for the lexicographic composition of two binary relations to be acyclic. It is observed that if the second stage binary relation is acyclic, then the lexicographic composition is acyclic if and only if the first stage binary relation is. All our binary relations are assumed to be reflexive and complete. Such binary relations are called abstract games.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

Harnessing Multiple Mental Models and Creating Opportunities for learning about Human Resource Issues among District Health officers

Neharika Vohra

This paper describes and evaluates the experience of using soft systems methodology (SSM), a problem structuring method of soft operations research (OR), to create learning opportunities about "people issues" among District Health Officers working in the government health system. A one-day workshop on human resource issues was facilitated using SSM. The workshop was part of a ten-day training program, titled "National Health Programmes and Management Issues in Health Organisations", for District Health Officers from two states of India, Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat. SSM was preferred over a simple discussion or a question answer session because it allowed participants to engage in self-learning and coordinate multiple perceptions of a given situation. Rich picture building one of the tools of SSM was used for facilitating the workshop. The use of SSM helped generate a creative learning situation and provided both the participants and the trainers an opportunity to understand human resource issues faced by those working in the government health department.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

Transparancy in Economy: Curbing Corruption

Singh J P

Transparency International's year 1999 Corruption Perception Index places India as the 28th most corrupt country in the world. This is a Slippage Improvement of six positions over 1998 achievement, notwithstanding addition of new countries to the list. This international honour has merited a very serious attention of the government and, understandably, several of its departments are working overtime to look into the matter. The paper looks at some of the alternatives available for implementation, though in a satirical vein.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

Vote Aggregators : Some Axiomatic Characterizations

Lahiri Somdeb

In this paper a model for the aggregation of ballot profiles is considered. In this framework three new results are obtained: the characterization of oligarchic aggregators, the characterization of the plurality aggregator and the non-existence of a vote aggregator which is anonymous and yet preserves proximity.

Read More

Working Papers | 2000

A Requiem for Shareholders? The Acc Takeover an`d the Issues in Perspective

Venkiteswaran N